ld
See this word as a collocate cloud
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | against cunningham roseanna perth snp |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | against cunningham roseanna perth snp |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | against cunningham roseanna perth snp |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | against cunningham roseanna perth snp |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | against cunningham roseanna perth snp |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | against cunningham roseanna perth snp |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | alex neil central scotland snp |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | andrew wilson central scotland snp |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | attended the following members also |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | gordon jackson glasgow govan lab |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | i have a brief question |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | i refer to figure 14 |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | i would like the minister |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | mr jamie mcgrigor highlands and |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | mr lloyd quinan west of |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| keith mid scotland and fife | ld | robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rose tricia marwick sorry i |
| euan macfarlane roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles michael john west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | scott tavish shetland ld sheridan |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | scott tavish shetland ld simpson |
| berwickshire ld scott tavish shetland | ld | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp simpson |
| berwickshire ld scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | support for the february 15 |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | the convener the result of |
| robson euan roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | the presiding officer the result |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | the regulation of investigatory powers |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | this has been an interesting |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| euan robson roxburgh and berwickshire | ld | we have already heard about |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | alex johnstone north east scotland |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | attended clerk to the committee |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | committee substitutes george lyon argyll |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | committee substitutes mr keith harding |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | dr elaine murray dumfries lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | duncan hamilton fergus ewing duncan |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | i am glad that mr |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | i congratulate irene mcgugan on |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | i most certainly was not |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | i note from our briefing |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | i thank the convener and |
| snp sir david steel lothians | ld | mr jamie stone caithness sutherland |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | mr kenny macaskill lothians snp |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | ms sandra white glasgow snp |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | nicola sturgeon glasgow snp attended |
| stephen nicol ross aberdeen south | ld | stone jamie hume caithness sutherland |
| ld smith margaret edinburgh west | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld smith margaret edinburgh west | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld stephen nicol aberdeen south | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| ld smith margaret edinburgh west | ld | stone mr jamie caithness sutherland |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | sturgeon nicola glasgow snp swinney |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | the great thing about having |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | the minister will be aware |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | the minister will know that |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | thomson elaine aberdeen north lab |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | what were the effects of |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | when i was a child |
| caithness sutherland and easter ross | ld | witnesses mr frank mcaveety deputy |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | committee members bill butler glasgow |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | committee members fergus ewing inverness |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | does the minister agree that |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | dr richard simpson ochil lab |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | i agree with what you |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | i declare an interest i |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | i do not think that |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | i think that we could |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | i welcome the direction that |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | i welcome the minister s |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | in the scottish secondary teachers |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | irene mcgugan north east scotland |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johann lamont glasgow pollok lab |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnston nick mid scotland and |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnston paul nicholas mid scotland |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | johnstone alex north east scotland |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | kerr mr andy east kilbride |
| ian tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | livingstone marilyn kirkcaldy lab lyon |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | mr nick johnston mid scotland |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | mr tom mccabe hamilton south |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | phil gallie south of scotland |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | presiding officer you should turn |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | trish godman west renfrewshire lab |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | we should go with that |
| jenkins tweeddale ettrick and lauderdale | ld | will the member give way |
| con donald gorrie central scotland | ld | mike watson glasgow cathcart lab |
| con wallace james robert orkney | ld | watson michael goodall glasgow cathcart |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| snp wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | watson mike glasgow cathcart lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| central lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| central lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| central lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | butler bill glasgow anniesland lab |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | brian fitzpatrick strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | fitzpatrick brian strathkelvin and bearsden |
| james ross west of scotland | ld | g galbraith samuel laird strathkelvin |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| finnie ross west of scotland | ld | galbraith mr sam strathkelvin and |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | attended clerk to the committee |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | attended witnesses rhona brankin deputy |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | bill aitken glasgow con linda |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | christine grahame south of scotland |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | committee members karen gillon clydesdale |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | deputy convener tricia marwick mid |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | does johann lamont agree that |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | elaine smith coatbridge and chryston |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | i want to focus on |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | jackie baillie started the debate |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | like many other contributors to |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | mrs margaret smith edinburgh west |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | on a point of order |
| john west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | russell michael william south of |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scanlon mary highlands and islands |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scott john ayr con simpson |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scott tavish shetland ld simpson |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scott tavish shetland ld simpson |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | scott tavish shetland ld simpson |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp simpson |
| kincardine ld scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| kincardine ld scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| kincardine ld scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| mike west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| rumbles west aberdeenshire and kincardine | ld | the minister will recall that |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | ben wallace north east scotland |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | david mcletchie lothians con the |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | given how critical it is |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | i begin by expressing my |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | i have a few points |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | i pledge the liberal democrats |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | i put on the record |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | i thank john swinney for |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | i welcome the opportunity to |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | kate maclean dundee west lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | m mcallion john dundee east |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macdonald lewis aberdeen central lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macintosh mr kenneth eastwood lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macintosh mr kenneth eastwood lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macintosh mr kenneth eastwood lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macintosh mr kenneth eastwood lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | macintosh mr kenneth eastwood lab |
| lyon george argyll and bute | ld | mcgrigor mr jamie highlands and |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | mr alasdair morrison western isles |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | mr duncan hamilton highlands and |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | mr jamie mcgrigor highlands and |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | mr john mcallion dundee east |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | mr kenneth macintosh eastwood lab |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | ms margo macdonald lothians snp |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | pauline mcneill glasgow kelvin lab |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | the liberal democrats too support |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | to ask the first minister |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| george lyon argyll and bute | ld | tricia marwick mid scotland and |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | dr richard simpson ochil lab |
| ayr con scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| ayr con scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| ayr con scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| ayr con scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| ayr con scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| ayr con scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| ayr con scott tavish shetland | ld | simpson dr richard ochil lab |
| lab nicol stephen aberdeen south | ld | 11 52 dr ewing we |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| smith mrs margaret edinburgh west | ld | stephen nicol aberdeen south ld |
| sir david martin scott lothians | ld | stephen nicol ross aberdeen south |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | campbell colin west of scotland |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | chisholm malcolm edinburgh north and |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | chisholm malcolm edinburgh north and |
| midlothian lab brown robert glasgow | ld | chisholm malcolm edinburgh north and |
| midlothian lab robert brown glasgow | ld | murdo fraser mid scotland and |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | rumbles mr mike west aberdeenshire |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | abstentions eadie helen dunfermline east |
| ross finnie west of scotland | ld | agriculture and rural affairs as |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | at the outset i must |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | attended the following also attended |
| ross finnie west of scotland | ld | donald gorrie central scotland ld |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | dr elaine murray dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | dr winnie ewing highlands and |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | for clarification what is the |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | i congratulate rhona brankin on |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | i wish to reiterate earlier |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | in view of the fact |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | irene oldfather cunninghame south lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | mr jamie mcgrigor highlands and |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | mr john home robertson east |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | mr kenny macaskill lothians snp |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | ms sandra white glasgow snp |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray dr elaine dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | murray elaine kildare dumfries lab |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | the building scotland bill is |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | to ask the first minister |
| ross skye and inverness west | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | mr andy kerr east kilbride |
| lab brown robert edward glasgow | ld | c campbell colin maciver west |
| con donald gorrie central scotland | ld | colin campbell west of scotland |
| con mr jim wallace orkney | ld | dennis canavan falkirk west i |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | deputy convener margaret jamieson kilmarnock |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | deputy convener margaret jamieson kilmarnock |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | does the first minister agree |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | following yesterday s announcement of |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | i am pleased to speak |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | i will read from the |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | kay ullrich west of scotland |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | margaret jamieson kilmarnock and loudoun |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | michael russell south of scotland |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | miss annabel goldie west of |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | mr raeburn made the passing |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | ms sandra white glasgow snp |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | nicola sturgeon glasgow snp witnesses |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | on a point of order |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | sarah boyack edinburgh central lab |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith margaret edinburgh west ld |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith margaret edinburgh west ld |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith margaret edinburgh west ld |
| iain william north east fife | ld | smith margaret joy edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith iain north east fife | ld | smith mrs margaret edinburgh west |
| smith margaret joy edinburgh west | ld | steel sir david martin scott |
| mrs margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | what we are seeing today |
| 2966 margaret smith edinburgh west | ld | world asthma day 7 may |
| linlithgow lab tavish scott shetland | ld | attended witnesses dr alastair brown |
| south lab tavish scott shetland | ld | ben wallace north east scotland |
| the oath tavish scott shetland | ld | elaine smith coatbridge and chryston |
| scotland con tavish scott shetland | ld | elaine thomson aberdeen north lab |
| the law tavish scott shetland | ld | in your opening remarks you |
| con scott tavish hamilton shetland | ld | sheridan tommy glasgow ssp simpson |
| agriculture 1 tavish scott shetland | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| services 1 tavish scott shetland | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | andrew wilson central scotland snp |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | attended the following also attended |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | bill aitken glasgow con colin |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | christine grahame south of scotland |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | clerk to the committee jennifer |
| deputy convener nora radcliffe gordon | ld | committee members bruce crawford mid |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | i agree with john swinney |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | i agree with the minister |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | i congratulate irene oldfather on |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | i congratulate the social justice |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | i would have preferred the |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | in the past four months |
| lab donald gorrie central scotland | ld | murdo fraser mid scotland and |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | on a point of order |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | on that point and what |
| snp r radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan keith william twort mid |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | raffan mr keith mid scotland |
| twort mid scotland and fife | ld | reid george newlands mid scotland |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | richard lochhead north east scotland |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | the following members made a |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | there are two issues at |
| raffan mid scotland and fife | ld | what assurance can the first |
| 1890 mr jim wallace orkney | ld | crime that the parliament welcomes |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | welsh mr andrew angus snp |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| lab wallace mr jim orkney | ld | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| con wallace mr jim orkney | ld | whitefield karen airdrie and shotts |
| 17 33 nora radcliffe gordon | ld | about this time last year |
| scotland snp nora radcliffe gordon | ld | ben wallace north east scotland |
| ayr con nora radcliffe gordon | ld | bristow muldoon livingston lab fiona |
| deputy convener nora radcliffe gordon | ld | committee members robin harper lothians |
| fife snp nora radcliffe gordon | ld | des mcnulty clydebank and milngavie |
| scotland snp nora radcliffe gordon | ld | des mcnulty clydebank and milngavie |
| buchan snp nora radcliffe gordon | ld | fiona hyslop lothians snp the |
| be created nora radcliffe gordon | ld | i am concerned that we |
| 17 42 nora radcliffe gordon | ld | i endorse wholeheartedly every word |
| do so nora radcliffe gordon | ld | i was interested by the |
| 15 37 nora radcliffe gordon | ld | i welcome the fact that |
| 09 50 nora radcliffe gordon | ld | in a previous existence i |
| east lab nora radcliffe gordon | ld | irene mcgugan north east scotland |
| east lab radcliffe nora gordon | ld | robison shona north east scotland |
| regulatory regime nora radcliffe gordon | ld | the minister is investigating having |
| lab abstentions radcliffe nora gordon | ld | the presiding officer the result |
| authority 4 nora radcliffe gordon | ld | to ask the first minister |
| a96 11 nora radcliffe gordon | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| recycling 13 nora radcliffe gordon | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | attended the following also attended |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | i am a little bemused |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | i take it that you |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | i thank keith harding for |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | i thank the minister for |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | many of my concerns have |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | ms sandra white glasgow snp |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | ms sandra white glasgow snp |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | on the issue of the |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | referral of ssi s that |
| iain smith north east fife | ld | this is rather a strange |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| con gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| lab gorrie donald central scotland | ld | grant rhoda highlands and islands |
| ld donald gorrie central scotland | ld | rhoda grant highlands and islands |
| committee substitutes robert brown glasgow | ld | angus mackay edinburgh south lab |
| con donald gorrie central scotland | ld | angus mackay edinburgh south lab |
| central lab brown robert glasgow | ld | chisholm malcolm edinburgh north and |
| central lab brown robert glasgow | ld | chisholm malcolm edinburgh north and |
| con donald gorrie central scotland | ld | dr sylvia jackson stirling lab |
| lab donald gorrie central scotland | ld | fiona hyslop lothians snp paul |
| members donald gorrie central scotland | ld | gordon jackson glasgow govan lab |
| snp donald gorrie central scotland | ld | janis hughes glasgow rutherglen lab |
| lab donald gorrie central scotland | ld | phil gallie south of scotland |
| green party lab scottish labour | ld | scottish liberal democrats snp scottish |
| valley lab robert brown glasgow | ld | the deputy minister for communities |
| donald cameron easterbrook central scotland | ld | grahame christine south of scotland |
| 58 donald gorrie central scotland | ld | i feel rather like an |
| occasion donald gorrie central scotland | ld | i have some questions that |
| 00 donald gorrie central scotland | ld | i join those who paid |
| 36 donald gorrie central scotland | ld | i thank andy kerr and |
| committee donald gorrie central scotland | ld | i think that the covenant |
| 23 donald gorrie central scotland | ld | i will concentrate on two |
| scott donald gorrie central scotland | ld | in the light of the |
| 02 donald gorrie central scotland | ld | in the stage 1 debate |
| glasgow snp robert brown glasgow | ld | mrs lyndsay mcintosh central scotland |
| snp donald gorrie central scotland | ld | ms margo macdonald lothians snp |
| 02 donald gorrie central scotland | ld | on behalf of the young |
| snp donald gorrie central scotland | ld | phil gallie south of scotland |
| version donald gorrie central scotland | ld | sometimes the number of questions |
| 08 donald gorrie central scotland | ld | the report is interesting i |
| seriously donald gorrie central scotland | ld | will the minister broaden his |
| glasgow con robert brown glasgow | ld | cathie craigie cumbernauld and kilsyth |
| committee members robert brown glasgow | ld | cathie craigie cumbernauld and kilsyth |
| service users robert brown glasgow | ld | does linda fabiani think that |
| 17 33 robert brown glasgow | ld | i add my welcome to |
| the officials robert brown glasgow | ld | i am bound to say |
| 10 30 robert brown glasgow | ld | i apologise for arriving at |
| 15 39 robert brown glasgow | ld | i hesitate to follow in |
| 10 15 robert brown glasgow | ld | i start by adding my |
| s letter robert brown glasgow | ld | i too welcome the minister |
| scotland con robert brown glasgow | ld | karen whitefield airdrie and shotts |
| scotland con robert brown glasgow | ld | karen whitefield airdrie and shotts |
| scotland snp robert brown glasgow | ld | the following members took the |
| sector more robert brown glasgow | ld | there has been quite a |
| 11 57 robert brown glasgow | ld | this has been a high |
| truancy 12 robert brown glasgow | ld | to ask the scottish executive |
| stood sir david steel lothians | ld | stood dr ewing the election |
Top
